Caretaking and Letting Agreement Essentials Part 2: Finance Deeds

15 September 14

In New South Wales, it is important to detail financiers’ rights in the Caretaking and Letting Agreements or the By-Laws (or both). I say this because the Strata Schemes Management Act 1996 does not recognise the role of financiers – unlike in Queensland.
Management rights are an industry and for any industry to develop, there must be Banks prepared to lend to that industry against the security of the Caretaking and Letting Agreements. However, Banks will not lend without entering into a Finance Deed with the Owners Corporation. These Finance Deeds have different names depending on which Bank you are talking to. They are often referred to as “Right of Entry Deeds” and “Deeds of Consent”.


What are they?
They are essentially a tripartite Agreement between the Owners Corporation, the Manager and the Bank to ensure that the Bank’s security is not jeopardised if the Caretakers default under its loan facility with the Bank or under the Caretaking Agreement. The Agreements allow the financier to “step in” to the Caretakers role, rectify any default and continue to operate the business as a going concern pending a sale. In other words, they give the Bank the ability to preserve its security in circumstances where the Owners Corporation might otherwise be entitled to terminate the Agreement.

Negotiating the terms of these Finance Deeds with Owners Corporations and their solicitors is becoming increasingly more difficult. Owners Corporations do not like these Deeds restricting their rights under the Caretaking Agreement in the event of a default. Consequently, when negotiating and drafting Caretaking Agreements or By-Laws, it is best to agree upfront on the terms that are to go into the Finance Deed.


The Queensland Position
Queensland had the same problem as New South Wales in relation to negotiating the terms of these Deeds over 15 years ago. After much consultation between the management rights industry, the banking industry and the unit owner groups, Queensland incorporated section 123 into the Body Corporate and Community Management Act 1997. This section legislates the financiers’ rights and Finance Deeds were subsequently outlawed.

Unfortunately, similar rights are not included in the Strata Schemes Management Act 1996. Consequently, every Deed has to be negotiated, which is adding considerable expense and time to every management rights sale or purchase in New South Wales.

 

Fair Content
When drafting your Caretaking and Letting Agreements or By-Laws, in my view, there is no better place than to start with the Queensland legislation. This section was heavily negotiated between industry participants at the time that the section was introduced into the Queensland legislation, with the Government considering it a fair balance between the interests of all parties.

One would think that a replication of these terms into a New South Wales Finance Deed would be the simple and most effective way to proceed. What I have found however is that for some reason, when financiers lend against management rights in New South Wales, their lawyers expect and demand terms to be incorporated in the Deeds which are well in excess of what the Banks are entitled to in Queensland.

One difference between the two States however is that in New South Wales, when the “functions” of a Caretaker are “transferred”, the owners must consent by way of an ordinary resolution at a General Meeting. In other words, an AGM or an EGM must approve such transfer.

Some New South Wales strata lawyers argue that the “transfer” occurs as soon as a Receiver or Nominee is appointed by the Bank. I disagree with this view because it is still the same caretaking entity that holds the management rights and there has been no “transfer” of the Caretaker’s “functions” to a third party. If you accepted this argument, every time the Manager went on holiday and put in a Nominee (approved by the Executive Committee) you would still have to go to a General Meeting of the Owners Corporation for approval in accordance with the section.

Most certainly, when the Bank ultimately finds a buyer for the business and seeks the Owners Corporation’s consent to the transfer of the Caretaking and Letting Agreement to that buyer, such consent must be obtained at a General Meeting of the Owners Corporation. Section 40B of the Act demands this and financiers need to acknowledge that that is the law in New South Wales. However, nearly all Caretaking and Letting Agreements provide that any assignment or transfer of the Caretaker’s functions to a third party can only take place if the transferee is a respectable, solvent person capable of properly performing their duties. There is an obligation on the Owners Corporation to act reasonably when making such a decision at a General Meeting.


Summary
If the Banks are prepared to lend billions of dollars against management rights in Queensland based solely on the rights contained in section 123 of the Body Corporate and Community Management Act, they should seek no more when crossing the border into New South Wales. They must also recognise that any final transfer of the Caretaking and Letting Agreement to a third party has to be approved by the Owners Corporation at a General Meeting and not by the Committee – which is the case in Queensland.

Also, a bit of give and take and commonsense is required to be exercised by all parties involved for this process to work.
 

Share

Contact Us Now

Phone:+ 61 7 5552 6666
Fax:+ 61 7 5528 0955
Email:info@smh.net.au
Address:Level 2, 17 Welch St Southport, Qld, 4215
Postal:PO Box 1876
Southport 4215

Search

Search*
Search

Most Popular Articles

Management Rights News

Number of news items returned: 1 to 15 records of 83

The Different Types of Caretaking Agreements

17 November 2014

(10826 views)

 Essentially, there are three types of caretaking agreements in the marketplace: “Do” agreements; “Supervisory” agreements; Hybrid “Do” and “Supervisory” agreements. “Do” Agreements A “Do” agreement ...

Unit Entitlement in NSW

11 February 2013

(8326 views)

The issue of unit entitlement was recently looked at again as part of the Department of Fair Trading’s Discussion Paper ...

CARETAKING AND LETTING AGREEMENT ESSENTIALS PART 5: DISPUTE RESOLUTION AND TERMINATION

16 July 2015

(7090 views)

This month, we continue our examination of various clauses within caretaking and letting agreements and the important considerations to be ...

What Managers Need to know about the NSW Child Window Safety Devices Act 2013

17 January 2014

(6682 views)

Resident building managers have general obligations under their Caretaking Agreements to assist Owners Corporations with building and compliance issues. Managers ...

Is it Time to Change the Management Rights Model?

13 May 2013

(6460 views)

I think the time is right for the management rights industry to explore the creation of a new model. I ...

The Law Relating to Management Rights in Queensland

14 June 2010

(5178 views)

This article looks at the legislation in Queensland dealing with the constraints and obligations imposed on developers whilst they control ...

Be Careful with your Proxies!

03 October 2013

(5125 views)

In June this year, I wrote an article headed “Proxy Farming”, which set out the relevant restrictions on caretakers using ...

Duty Bound or Duty Free - Do you know what Your Duties Are?

23 September 2013

(4653 views)

The day-to-day care and maintenance of your resort facilities and communal areas is essential to its ongoing performance and success. ...

Owners Corporation Insurance - How do we Stop the Spiraling Costs?

12 August 2013

(4447 views)

In NSW, all strata schemes are required to be insured for the full replacement value, as well as public liability ...

Caretaking and Letting Agreement Essentials Part 1

03 September 2014

(4192 views)

We regularly prepare caretaking and letting agreements for new developments. However, it has become increasingly common for us to be ...

Proxy Farming

10 June 2013

(4190 views)

It is often stated that Strata and Community Schemes represent the “fourth tier of Government” and, as such, voting (either ...

For Your Eyes Only!

15 April 2013

(4163 views)

Information is a commodity and for many, information is power. As you would most likely know from personal experience, the right ...

"Legal Action", All those in Favour say "Why"

15 July 2013

(4052 views)

I was recently involved in a New South Wales matter where an Executive Committee had received extensive legal advice from ...

Manged Investment Schemes

15 July 2008

(3739 views)

You may have heard the terms ‘MIA’ or ‘Managed Investments Scheme’ and wondered what it’s all about. If you operate ...

Being Aware of your Rights and Responsibilities

14 January 2013

(3713 views)

Every resident building manager in NSW should have a copy of the booklet issued by the Department of Fair Trading ...